Pizza Pies

Pizza Pies

Build Your Own Pizza Pies

We’ll make them just the way you want.

Start here: Slice: $2.95     12″ Capone: $10.95     Gluten Free (14″) or 18″ Don: $15.95 ….then add your favorite toppings from below.

Average Joe Toppings

Slice + $.75     Capone + $1.95     Don + $3.75

Anchovies – Bacon – Basil – Black Olive – Broccoli – Extra Cheese – Garlic – Green Olives – Green Peppers – Ham – Jalapeños – Mushrooms – Pepperoni – Pepperoncini – Plum Tomato – Red Onion – Red Peppers – Salami – Italian Sausage

 Primo Toppings

Slice + $1.75     Capone + $3.25     Don + $4.50

Artichoke – Arugula – Blue Cheese – Roasted Chicken (Plain, BBQ, Buffalo, or Hot) – Chorizo – Eggplant – Feta – Spicy Link Sausage – Kalamata Olives – Informant Mix –  Meatballs (Sliced or Ground) – Pecorino Romano – Pesto – Pineapple –  Portobella – Prosciutto – Spinach – Sun Dried Tomato – Salame Toscano – Zucchini – Any Piccolo Morsi Items

Wicked Good Toppings

Slice + $2.25     Capone + $4.50      Don + $6.75

Goat Cheese – MAFIAOZA’S Homemade Mozzarella – Truffle Salt – Caramelized Onions – Peppadew Peppers – Ricotta



The Rico Act

It’s so good, it’s criminal, but the feds got nothin’ on us! Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms & caramelized onions.

$22.75 & $28.75

The Bellagio

Saltimbocca is not just for pasta anymore! Featuring alfredo, prosciutto, eggplant & fresh sage.  Vegetarians, call in a hit on the prosciutto & get a bite of this tasty pie!

$24.00 & $30.00

The Santa Margherita

Our traditional margherita style pizza, featuring our homemade mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, olive oil & tons of fresh basil to bring you back to old Napoli!

$15.95 & $21.95

The Fedora

Our famous crust covered with basil pesto topped with whole kalamata olives & fresh mozzarella.  You don’t need to be a tough guy to enjoy a good Fedora!

$16.00 & $21.00


The Associate

For those working their way up the Family tree. A traditional pie of pepperoni and our cheese blend.

$12.90 & $19.70

Brother Fredo

For people on the sly. Spinach and alfredo with roasted chicken, artichokes and cheese.

$20.50 & $27.50

The Long Vacation

For the few who might have to get away. Pineapple, ham and mozzarella cheese.

$15.50 & $22.00

The DeMartino

‘Cuz he’s not gonna tell you twice. Salame toscano, sun dried tomatoes, goat cheese and our homemade mozzarella topped with arugula and a basil chiffonade.

$26.00 & $33.50

Brass Knuckles

This pie is for all the people in Buffalo. Our spicy wing sauce, blue cheese crumbles and roasted chicken, tossed in our spicy wing sauce and our famous cheese blend. “Guardar dal mangiatore,” or beware, eater!

$19.00 & $26.00

The Irate Italian

The Don ain’t irate about this. Our secret tomato sauce, fresh garlic, pecorino romano cheese, black olives and mozzarella cheese.

$16.00 & $21.00

The Greek

For our Greek brothers. Plum tomatoes, red onion, green peppers, black olives, feta cheese and a creamy greek vinaigrette.

$16.00 & $21.00

The Last Request

One bite and you’ll think you’re in heaven. black olives, extra cheese, pepperoni, salami, italian sausage, portobello mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, garlic, green peppers, red onion and jalapeños.

$21.95 & $29.95

The Informant

So good you’ll want to tell everyone. Roasted veggies (mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes and red peppers) with our basil alfredo sauce.

$15.95 & $21.95

 The Dolan

The Dolan is known in many circles as “The Family’s Attorney.” Spicy B.B.Q. chicken with our blend of cheeses and a BBQ sauce base.

$15.95 & $21.95

The Teamster

Good enough to make Jimmy proud. Bacon, Italian sausage, salami and pepperoni.

$18.00 & $25.50